Every brand has a bottom end — the tenth percentile of its listings, where the high-mileage and hard-luck examples live. For most premium marques that number is surprisingly low.
| Brand | Bottom decile | Listings |
|---|---|---|
| Tesla | $13,900 | 1,465 |
| Porsche | $9,950 | 1,610 |
| RAM | $8,800 | 11,639 |
| Land Rover | $6,999 | 1,825 |
| Mercedes-Benz | $4,475 | |
| BMW | $3,999 |
A bottom-end BMW costs $3,999
That's the whole point of the table. "Cheap old German luxury car" is a real, well-populated segment of the market — a fifteen-year-old 5-Series with 160,000 miles is a thing you can buy for four thousand dollars, with all the maintenance consequences that implies.
A bottom-end BMW is only $299 cheaper than a bottom-end Toyota, which says something about how far a luxury badge falls.
Tesla doesn't do this. Its floor sits at $13,900 — the highest of any brand with 500+ listings on the market.
Why the floor is so high
The fleet is young. Tesla volume only became significant around 2018, so there simply aren't many fifteen-year-old examples to be worn out and dumped. The cars that would form a cheap tier haven't aged into it yet.
Mileage barely moves the price. We measured this separately: on a 2020 Model 3, 1,000 miles costs $7.40, or 0.034% of the car's value, against 0.943% for a Dodge. High mileage is the usual route to a cheap used car, and on a Tesla that route barely exists.
The range is compressed. Tesla's spread from bottom decile to top is 3.42x — the narrowest of any large brand, against 12.80x for Chrysler and 12.33x for Volvo. Few configurations, few model years, little to disagree about.
What breaks the floor eventually
Two things, and neither has happened at scale yet.
Battery condition is the obvious one. When packs age past the point where replacement is economic, those cars will price accordingly — and that's a cliff rather than a slope, because a car needing a pack is worth very little.
The other is damage history. Tesla already has an unusually high branded-title rate: 11.97% of listings, well above the market and comparable to Subaru. Model 3 specifically runs 16.4%. Rebuilt examples are the cheap Teslas that exist today.
What to do with this
If you want an inexpensive EV, Tesla isn't the value play. The floor is high and the discount for miles is small. Other EVs depreciate more conventionally.
A cheap Tesla is cheap for a reason — find out which. Given the branded-title rate, a listing well below $13,900 deserves the title check before the test drive.
Check the battery before the odometer. On a Tesla the pack holds the value, and pack health depends on charging habits and climate far more than on distance driven.
A VIN check returns title brands and history in seconds. We looked at what mileage costs by brand in every 1,000 miles costs half a percent of the car, and at the used EV market overall in used EVs cost $4,000 more, except they don't.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest used Tesla?
The bottom decile of Tesla listings starts at $13,900 — the highest floor of any brand with 500+ listings. For comparison, Porsche's bottom decile is $9,950, Land Rover's $6,999 and BMW's $3,999.
Why are used Teslas so expensive at the bottom end?
The fleet is young, so there are few worn-out examples, and mileage barely affects price — 1,000 miles costs $7.40 on a 2020 Model 3 against 0.943% of value on a Dodge. High mileage is the usual route to a cheap used car and it barely applies here.
Are there cheap Teslas at all?
Mostly rebuilt ones. Tesla's branded-title rate is 11.97% of listings, and 16.4% for the Model 3 specifically — well above the market average. A listing well below the floor usually has a title reason.
What should I check on a cheap used Tesla?
Title status first, given the branded-title rate, then battery health rather than the odometer. Pack condition depends on charging habits and climate far more than on distance driven, and it holds most of the car's value.
Denis Kataev is a serial solopreneur and the founder of ForCar. With 15+ years in software engineering and 10 years in SEO, he builds data-driven products end to end — backed by a sharp eye for design. At ForCar he mines proprietary vehicle datasets, turning raw numbers into buying advice you can actually trust.
Keep reading
All articles →
Every 1,000 Miles You Drive Costs About Half a Percent of the Car
Everyone knows mileage costs money. Nobody has a number for it. I worked out what 1,000 miles actually takes off a car, and the answer is portable across the whole market.
When Only Four People Are Selling Your Car, the Price Guide Is Guessing
Valuation tools return a number for any car you type in. For a lot of model years, that number is built on a handful of listings — and the fewer there are, the more certain it looks.
The Same 2001 F-250 Sells for $2,300 and for $38,000
Every valuation tool gives you one number for a model and year. I looked at what the listings for a single model year actually span, and the range makes the average almost meaningless.