Colour is the one specification everyone has an opinion about and nobody has data on. We have 157,000 listings with the paint colour recorded, so I sorted them by model year and watched what happened.
| Model year | Listings | White | Black |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2008 | 5,629 | 17% | |
| 2012 | 8,623 | 21% | |
| 2016 | 11,314 | 20% | |
| 2020 | 6,882 | 18% | |
| 2024 | 4,389 | 22% |
White nearly doubled its share in twelve years. Black stayed almost exactly where it was. Everything else got squeezed.
Four things pushed it
Fleets. Rental companies and corporate fleets buy white because it's the cheapest to order, easiest to resell in volume and simplest to rebrand with vinyl. Those cars hit the used market on a three-year cycle, which is exactly the lag you see in the table.
Paint technology. Pearlescent and tri-coat whites arrived in the mid-2010s and turned white from the base-model default into something manufacturers charge extra for. "White" on a 2020 car often isn't the same paint as white on a 2008 one.
Heat. A white roof genuinely runs cooler than a black one, which matters in the Sun Belt states where a large share of American cars live — and matters more on an electric car, where cabin cooling comes out of the battery.
Screens. This one is speculative but hard to ignore: white photographs well, and a decade of configurators, launch photography and social media has made it the default colour people picture when they picture a new car.
The colour that lost
Silver is the casualty. It was everywhere in the 2000s and has been shrinking since — the shade that said "modern" in 2005 now reads as dated, which is the fate of every colour that becomes ubiquitous. Give white fifteen years.
Does any of this affect what your car is worth?
No — and we checked properly, because this is where colour advice usually goes wrong.
Compare raw averages and white cars look more expensive. Compare the same model and year in different colours and the difference vanishes. We ran that comparison across 306,046 listings and wrote it up in does car colour affect resale value. The short version: the apparent premium is a composition effect. White is over-represented on trucks and SUVs, which cost more than the sedans where you'll find the greens and the reds.
What colour does affect is time to sell, not price. Common colours find a buyer faster because more people will accept them. If you're planning to sell privately, that's the whole argument — and our listings turn over in under a week on average regardless.
So buy what you want
The practical takeaway is unusually simple. Colour won't cost you money when you sell, so choose on the things that actually differ: a dark car shows swirl marks and heats up more, a light one hides both and shows road grime sooner.
The one place colour genuinely matters is matching paint after a repair. If you're buying used, ask for the paint code — it's on a sticker in the door jamb, never in the VIN, whatever the internet says. We covered what the VIN does and doesn't encode on the decoder page.
Frequently asked questions
What percentage of cars are white?
Around 38–40% of recent model years in our listings, up from 23% of 2008 cars. Black has stayed roughly flat at 17–22% across the same period.
Why did white cars become so popular?
Fleet buying (white is cheapest to order and easiest to rebrand), the arrival of pearlescent paints that made white a premium option, heat reflection in hot states, and a decade of white cars dominating launch photography.
Do white cars hold their value better?
No. Raw averages suggest they do, but that's a composition effect — white is over-represented on trucks and SUVs. Compare the same model and year in different colours and the difference disappears.
Does car colour affect how fast it sells?
Yes, more than it affects price. Common colours find buyers faster because more people will accept them, which matters if you're selling privately rather than trading in.
Denis Kataev is a serial solopreneur and the founder of ForCar. With 15+ years in software engineering and 10 years in SEO, he builds data-driven products end to end — backed by a sharp eye for design. At ForCar he mines proprietary vehicle datasets, turning raw numbers into buying advice you can actually trust.
Keep reading
All articles →
Flex-Fuel Peaked at 689 Models. Now It Is Gone.
A technology fitted to hundreds of models disappeared inside a decade, and almost nobody noticed because most of the cars that had it never used it. The reason it existed explains why it stopped.
Pontiac Died in 2010. It Still Sells 42% Below a Chevrolet.
A dead badge on a car that shares its engine, gearbox and platform with a living one is the cleanest natural experiment the used market offers. The market charges a lot less for it, and the parts situation is nothing like as bad as the price implies.
Arizona Sells 38% White Cars. Wisconsin Sells 20%.
The colour split between states is almost twice as wide as anything you would guess, and it lines up with latitude. The price gap between colours looks just as dramatic until you control for how old the cars are.
Mark ForCar as a preferred source and our data shows up first in your Google results. One click, no account.