Ford Draws the Most NHTSA Investigations. Tesla Draws the Most for Its Size.

Counting every defect investigation NHTSA has aimed at a single manufacturer since 2005, the big Detroit groups lead on volume. Adjusted for how many complaints each brand gets, the picture flips toward Tesla and the German premium makers.

By ·Nov 16, 2026·2 min read
Illustration of a sedan
Share

Since 2005, NHTSA has opened 104 defect investigations that concern Ford vehicles alone, more than for any other manufacturer. Stellantis is second with 100 and General Motors third with 90.

This count includes only preliminary evaluations and engineering analyses aimed at a single manufacturer. Industry-wide cases, such as the Takata airbag inflators, are left out because they cover dozens of brands at once.

FIG.01·NHTSA defect investigations by manufacturer since 2005
ManufacturerInvestigations since 2005Ended in a recallPer 10,000 complaints
Ford10442%6.3
Stellantis (Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, RAM)10039%6.5
General Motors9034%5.4
Honda and Acura5153%6.3
Hyundai and Kia5056%6.0
Nissan and Infiniti4141%7.1
Toyota and Lexus3438%4.2
Volkswagen Group3033%9.3
BMW2646%16.5
Mercedes-Benz1942%27.9
Tesla1921%30.3
Subaru771%3.3
ROWS 12·SOURCE NHTSA investigations and complaints via ForCar

The raw count mostly reflects size. Ford, Stellantis and GM sell the most vehicles and receive the most complaints, so they draw the most investigations.

Adjusted for complaints

The last column divides investigations by the complaints each manufacturer's owners filed over the same period. On that measure the big three Detroit groups, Honda and Hyundai-Kia are all close together, at five to seven investigations per 10,000 complaints. Toyota is lower at 4.2 and Subaru lowest at 3.3.

At the other end, the luxury and electric brands stand out. Their owners file fewer complaints, but the agency investigates them often. Tesla has 30 investigations per 10,000 complaints, Mercedes-Benz 28 and BMW 16.5.

Tesla's investigations are about software

Of Tesla's 19 investigations, at least eight concern how its cars drive themselves or brake on their own: Autopilot, Full Self-Driving, Smart Summon and unexpected braking. Only four of the 19 ended with a recall, the lowest share of any manufacturer. Several closed without one. In the case of Passenger Play, which let games run on the screen while driving, Tesla had already switched the feature off with a software update. One of the four that did end in a recall covered about two million Teslas with Autopilot.

The rest of Tesla's file looks more like everyone else's: steering, suspension links, a rearview camera, a seat belt anchor and door handles.

Who ends up recalling

Among the larger manufacturers, Hyundai-Kia and Honda turn investigations into recalls most often, more than half the time, and Subaru did so in five of its seven. GM, Volkswagen and Tesla do so least often, at a third or less. A lower share can mean the agency's concern turned out to be unfounded, or that the manufacturer fixed the problem another way. The record doesn't say which.

What it tells a buyer

Very little about any single car. Brand-level counts mix decades of models, and as our look at complaints per recall showed, brands differ widely in how much their owners complain in the first place. Investigations are also much rarer than they used to be, so the useful check is model-specific: any open investigation for the model and years you're looking at, and any open recall on the car itself, which a VIN check shows.

Frequently asked questions

Which car brand has the most NHTSA investigations?

Ford, with 104 defect investigations aimed at it alone since 2005, followed by Stellantis (100) and General Motors (90). Industry-wide investigations such as the Takata airbags are excluded.

How many NHTSA investigations has Tesla had?

19 single-manufacturer investigations since 2005, at least eight of them about Autopilot, Full Self-Driving, Smart Summon or unexpected braking. Four ended in a recall, the lowest share of any manufacturer. Relative to complaints, Tesla draws about 30 investigations per 10,000, against 4 to 7 for mainstream brands.

Does a brand's investigation count say anything about reliability?

Not much on its own. It reflects sales volume, how much owners complain, and how new a brand's technology is. For a specific car, check open investigations for that model and year and open recalls on the VIN.

brandsdatarecallssafety
Denis Kataev
Founder & Editor · Serial Solopreneur

Denis Kataev is a serial solopreneur and the founder of ForCar. With 15+ years in software engineering and 10 years in SEO, he builds data-driven products end to end — backed by a sharp eye for design. At ForCar he mines proprietary vehicle datasets, turning raw numbers into buying advice you can actually trust.

Keep reading

All articles →
Found this useful?

Mark ForCar as a preferred source and our data shows up first in your Google results. One click, no account.

Prefer ForCar →