About $1,417 a year for full coverage on a national average — within a few percent of the $1,438 average car. Insurers rate the Tesla Model Y at an index of 99 where 100 is a typical vehicle, based on how often and how expensively these cars actually generate claims (latest data covers 2022-2024).
The premium isn't spread evenly across the Tesla Model Y: Collision — damage to your own car in a crash — carries its highest loss index at 126, while Bodily injury sits at 79. Those 47 points are the real reason behind the price, and they are the part a quote form never shows you. Among 80 luxury suvs we hold data for, the Model Y ranks #27 from cheapest, below the class median of 109. Against what the car is worth the bill looks different again: a 2026 Model Y sells for a median $48,000, so a year of cover costs 3% of the car's value. Over 5 generations of data the index has climbed from 90 (2018-2020) to 99 (2022-2024). Calculated from 9 insurance-loss records and live US listing prices.
Why a Model Y costs what it does
Insurers don't price a car with one number — they track losses separately for each kind of cover. An index of 100 is the average vehicle, so anything above means this model generates costlier claims of that type:
Read it as «where the money goes». A high Collision figure means these cars are expensive to repair after a crash; a high Comprehensive figure points at theft, weather and vandalism instead. Estimated annual split at $1,417: Liability (BI + PD) $680 · Collision $397 · Comprehensive $170 · Other (UM / PIP) $170.
The Model Y against its class
Every luxury suvs we hold insurance data for, cheapest to insure first. The Model Y is highlighted — rivals are clickable if you're cross-shopping:
Class as defined by insurers (Luxury SUVs), not by us — it groups cars by how they're actually driven and repaired. Median for this class is 109, roughly $1,560 a year.
How it changed by generation
Insurance-loss index of the Model Y across every generation in the data. Newer isn't automatically cheaper — driver-assist systems cut crash frequency, while sensors and aluminium panels push repair bills up:
Each point averages every recorded variant of that generation. The Model Y has become more expensive to insure over time (+9 points).
What a Model Y costs by state
Where you park matters as much as what you drive. The Model Y's index applied to each state's average premium — the same car, the same cover, different postcode:
| State | Model Y est. / yr | vs national |
|---|---|---|
| Florida | +39% vs US | |
| Louisiana | +38% vs US | |
| New York | +32% vs US | |
| District of Columbia | +26% vs US | |
| Georgia | +21% vs US | |
| Texas | +20% vs US | |
| Wisconsin | -30% vs US | |
| Hawaii | -31% vs US | |
| Idaho | -32% vs US | |
| North Dakota | -33% vs US | |
| Vermont | -33% vs US | |
| Maine | -36% vs US |
Six priciest and six cheapest states shown. Figures are the state's average premium scaled by the Tesla Model Y's loss index of 99 — your own quote also depends on age, record, deductible and ZIP.
Tesla Model Y insurance — frequently asked
How much is insurance for a Tesla Model Y?
About $1,417 a year for full coverage at the national average, versus $1,438 for a typical car. That's the model's insurance-loss index of 99 applied to the US average premium.
Why is the Model Y expensive or cheap to insure?
For the Tesla Model Y the costliest area is Collision at an index of 126, covering damage to your own car in a crash — against 79 for its cheapest. Insurers set premiums from claim history like that, not from the sticker price — which is why the Tesla Model Y lands at 99, not at what it costs new.
Is the Model Y cheaper to insure than rivals?
It ranks #27 of 80 in the luxury suvs class, where the median index is 109 against this car's 99. Cheaper rivals are listed in the chart above.
Is that a lot relative to the car's value?
A year of cover is 3% of what a 2026 Model Y sells for — $1,417 against a median price of $48,000. Cheap cars often show a higher percentage even when the dollar premium is lower, and at 3% the Model Y sits on the cheap side of it.
Does its safety rating lower the premium?
Not directly. The Model Y holds 5 stars from NHTSA, but crash-test performance and repair cost are priced separately — a car can protect occupants well and still be costly to fix.
Where does this data come from?
Insurance-loss indices published for real vehicles, combined with NAIC state average premiums. It's claim history, not a quote engine — so it shows what these cars actually cost insurers rather than what one company would offer you.
Will my own quote match this?
Treat it as a baseline for the car itself. Your figure also moves with age, driving record, deductible, mileage and ZIP code — the same Model Y can differ by hundreds between two drivers.
How we work this out
Mark ForCar as a preferred source and our data shows up first in your Google results. One click, no account.