Having written about which brands recall the most, the obvious follow-up is the other end of the table. Kia averages 25 recalls per model, Mazda 26, Hyundai 26 — against Ford's 91. Tempting to read that as a quality ranking. It mostly isn't.
The bottom of the table
| Brand | Recalls per model | Total | Models |
|---|---|---|---|
| BMW | 17 | 2,182 | 125 |
| Kia | 25 | 589 | 24 |
| Mazda | 26 | 635 | 24 |
| Hyundai | 26 | 817 | 31 |
| Nissan | 41 | 1,263 | 31 |
| Subaru | 50 | 846 | 17 |
BMW's 17 per model is the lowest of any major brand — while its 2,182 total recalls is among the highest. Both facts are true, and they illustrate why the denominator decides the story.
Three things this number is really measuring
Time in market. Kia and Hyundai have sold in America for a fraction as long as Ford or Chevrolet. Fewer decades of production means fewer accumulated campaigns, regardless of build quality.
Model count. Spreading recalls across 125 model lines, as BMW does, produces a low per-model figure even when the absolute total is large.
Fleet size. A brand whose vehicles do heavy commercial duty accumulates reports faster than one whose cars mostly commute. That's part of why Ford and Subaru sit where they do — work trucks and high-mileage all-wheel-drive wagons surface faults early.
What the number is not measuring is how likely your specific car is to have an unresolved problem. That's a per-vehicle question, and checking the VIN answers it directly.
How I'd actually compare brands
Pair the recall rate with owner complaints, because together they say something the recall count alone can't. Many recalls plus few complaints suggests a manufacturer catching problems early. Few recalls plus many complaints is the combination to worry about.
Then drop to the model level, since brand averages hide enormous variation between individual cars — our model reliability data breaks it down that far. And whatever the badge says, a specific car with a clean, completed recall history beats a brand statistic every time.
Frequently asked questions
Which brand has the fewest recalls?
Per model, BMW at 17 — though its 2,182 total is among the highest, spread over 125 model lines. Among mainstream brands Kia is lowest at 25 per model.
Do fewer recalls mean better quality?
Not reliably. Time in the American market, number of model lines and how hard the vehicles are driven all shape the figure independently of build quality.
What is a better way to compare brands?
Pair recall rate with owner complaints. Many recalls with few complaints suggests problems caught early; few recalls with many complaints is the combination worth avoiding.
Denis Kataev is a serial solopreneur and the founder of ForCar. With 15+ years in software engineering and 10 years in SEO, he builds data-driven products end to end — backed by a sharp eye for design. At ForCar he mines proprietary vehicle datasets, turning raw numbers into buying advice you can actually trust.
Keep reading
All articles →
853 Explorer Owners Reported Exhaust in the Cabin. NHTSA Found No Defect.
One SUV generation produced half of every complaint about exhaust fumes inside a vehicle. The regulator spent six years on it and closed the case without a recall, and its findings tell a buyer exactly which Explorers to be careful with.
1,569 Complaints Describe a Death Wobble. Two Thirds Are Wranglers.
The violent front-end shake has a reputation as an old Jeep's problem. The complaint record says it's concentrated in the current generation, arrives at low mileage and has not gone away.
NHTSA Has 74 Open Defect Investigations. These Cover Cars You Can Buy Used.
Before a defect becomes a recall it sits in an investigation file, sometimes for years. Here are the ones open right now that cover cars on the used market, and what they mean for a buyer.
Mark ForCar as a preferred source and our data shows up first in your Google results. One click, no account.