Complaint counts usually get published per brand or per model. I grouped them by EPA vehicle class instead — the official categories that sort cars by what they physically are.
| Class | Complaints per model | Recalls per model |
|---|---|---|
| Standard pickup 2WD | 4,642 | 133 |
| Minivan 2WD | 3,431 | 61 |
| Small SUV 2WD | 2,477 | 42 |
| Special purpose | 2,341 | 58 |
| Standard SUV 2WD | 2,078 | 57 |
| Standard SUV 4WD | 1,834 | 50 |
4,642 against 1,834
A standard 2WD pickup averages two and a half times the complaints of a large 4WD SUV, and 133 recall campaigns per model against 50.
Part of that is volume — the F-150 and Silverado are the best-selling vehicles in America, so there are simply more owners available to file reports. But volume doesn't explain the recall figure. 133 campaigns per model is more than double any other class, and campaigns are counted per defect, not per owner.
Why trucks accumulate problems
They're used harder than anything else. Towing, hauling, job sites, unpaved roads. A pickup's duty cycle is closer to commercial equipment than to a passenger car, and components fail at rates that reflect that.
They're kept longer. More years on the road means more time to develop faults and file reports. Trucks dominate the high-mileage end of the used market.
They have more to go wrong. Transfer cases, heavy-duty transmissions, towing electronics, air suspension on the upper trims — systems a sedan doesn't have at all.
Owners notice. Someone whose income depends on the truck working reports a fault that a commuter would tolerate. Complaint databases measure how much a failure matters as much as how often it happens.
The minivan surprise
Second place at 3,431 is more interesting, because minivans are family vehicles rather than work vehicles.
What they share with trucks is duty: sliding doors cycled thousands of times, rear climate systems, folding seat mechanisms, and a full load of passengers most of the time. Minivans carry more moving parts in the cabin than any other body style, and moving parts are what generate complaints.
What a buyer should take from this
A high class average doesn't condemn any individual truck. It tells you the segment generates problems, which means the gap between a well-maintained example and a neglected one is at its widest here.
Service records matter more on a truck than on anything else. If the previous owner towed with it, that's not a disqualifier — it's a reason to want documentation of what was serviced and when.
Check for open campaigns specifically. At 133 recalls per model, the chance that a used pickup has unrepaired work is higher than in any other class, and the repairs are free regardless of how many owners it's had. A VIN check returns the open campaigns for that exact vehicle.
We looked at which component fails most across all classes in the most-reported car problem, and at how a brand's complaint volume compares to its recall count in complaints per recall by brand.
Frequently asked questions
Which type of vehicle gets the most complaints?
Standard 2WD pickups, averaging 4,642 owner complaints per model — roughly double the next class. They also carry 133 recall campaigns per model, more than twice any other category.
Why do pickup trucks have more problems?
They're used harder — towing, hauling and job-site duty put loads on components that passenger cars never see. They're also kept longer, have more systems that can fail, and their owners depend on them working, so faults get reported rather than tolerated.
Why do minivans rank second?
At 3,431 complaints per model they share the trucks' problem of duty cycle: sliding doors cycled thousands of times, rear climate systems and folding seat mechanisms mean more moving parts in the cabin than any other body style.
Does this mean I shouldn't buy a used pickup?
No — it means the gap between a maintained example and a neglected one is widest in this class. Service records matter more here than anywhere else, and with 133 recalls per model, checking for unrepaired campaigns is worth doing before you buy.
Denis Kataev is a serial solopreneur and the founder of ForCar. With 15+ years in software engineering and 10 years in SEO, he builds data-driven products end to end — backed by a sharp eye for design. At ForCar he mines proprietary vehicle datasets, turning raw numbers into buying advice you can actually trust.
Keep reading
All articles →
Jeep Owners File 76 Complaints for Every Recall. Lexus Owners File One.
Recall counts and complaint counts both get published, and both are misleading alone. I divided one by the other and got a number that says something neither does — how much trouble never turns into an official fix.
Volvo, BMW and Tesla Average a Perfect Five Stars. Jeep Averages 4.09.
Individual crash scores get quoted constantly. I averaged them across every model each brand sells instead, and one mainstream American brand stands out for a reason that's built into what it makes.
A Car's Complaint Count Multiplies by Six Between Year 2 and Year 12
Everyone knows old cars break more. Nobody says by how much or when it starts. I plotted complaints against age across our whole database and the curve has a clear shape — with one step that's much bigger than the rest.