4,105 Complaints Say the Car Shifted Into Neutral While Driving. The 2014 Cherokee Leads.

The engine keeps running but the car stops pulling, often in traffic. The complaint record points to a few transmissions in particular, one of them new in 2014, and to recalls that are worth checking on any used example.

By ·Nov 22, 2026·2 min read
Illustration of a compact SUV
Share

4,105 complaints filed with NHTSA describe a transmission that shifted, dropped or popped into neutral while the car was being driven. The engine keeps running, the revs flare and the car simply stops accelerating, often in traffic. 23.5% of these complaints mention a highway, and 4.2% involve a crash.

FIG.01·Complaints describing the transmission shifting into neutral
VehicleComplaints of shifting into neutralPer 1,000 complaints about the model
Jeep Cherokee20916
Jeep Grand Cherokee2088
Ford Focus1377
Ford Taurus1289
Honda Pilot10312
Acura MDX8729
Chrysler 2007921
Dodge Dart7234
ROWS 8·SOURCE NHTSA complaint text via ForCar

A new gearbox and a new car

FIG.02·Model years with the most complaints of shifting into neutral
Model yearComplaints
2014 Jeep Cherokee112
2015 Chrysler 20074
2014 Jeep Grand Cherokee52
2015 Jeep Cherokee46
2012 Dodge Dart45
2005 Ford Taurus43
ROWS 6·SOURCE NHTSA complaint text via ForCar

The worst single model year is the 2014 Jeep Cherokee, with 112 complaints. That was the first year of the Cherokee's return, and it was one of the first cars to use ZF's new nine-speed automatic. The 2015 Chrysler 200, the second-worst year, used the same transmission.

Chrysler recalled 2014 and 2015 Cherokees, 2015 Chrysler 200s, Jeep Renegades and Ram ProMasters, and 2016 Fiat 500Xs in 2016 because poorly crimped connections in the transmission wiring could make it shift into neutral. It recalled 2014 Cherokees with the 3.2-liter V6 again in 2019, after finding the software could select neutral if a clutch stuck.

Across all vehicles with that nine-speed, including Honda's and Acura's versions in the Pilot, Passport, Odyssey, MDX and TLX, there are 564 neutral complaints, one in seven of the total.

The 2012 to 2015 Dodge Dart is a separate case. Its control module could fail and drop the car into neutral, and that was recalled in 2015.

How it differs from a stall

A car that shifts into neutral still has its engine, power steering and brakes. That's why the crash rate is lower than for an engine that cuts out in traffic. But it can't accelerate out of trouble, and it often happens just as the driver asks for power: two complaints in five mention accelerating, merging or pulling out. One complaint in five ends with a tow, and one in five says it happened again after a repair.

Where owners gave a mileage, the median is 46,000 miles, and the typical car was four years old.

If it happens

Signal, steer for the shoulder and use the momentum you have. A quarter of these complaints describe getting going again after stopping, shifting into park or restarting the engine. Treat that as a way to get off the road, not a fix.

Buying one used

On a 2014 or 2015 Cherokee, a 2015 Chrysler 200 or Renegade, or a 2013 to 2015 Dart, check that the transmission recalls were done. A VIN check shows open campaigns. On the test drive, accelerate firmly from a slow roll, which is where many of these complaints say the problem showed. The full Cherokee complaint record breaks down the transmission's history by year.

Frequently asked questions

Why would a transmission shift into neutral while driving?

Common causes in the complaint record are wiring or sensor faults, transmission control module failures and software that selects neutral to protect a damaged transmission. Chrysler recalled several nine-speed models in 2016 over poorly crimped wiring connections that could cause it.

Which cars have the most complaints about shifting into neutral?

The Jeep Cherokee (209 NHTSA complaints) and Grand Cherokee (208), followed by the Ford Focus (137), Ford Taurus (128) and Honda Pilot (103). The 2014 Cherokee is the worst single model year with 112.

Is shifting into neutral dangerous?

Less than a stall, because steering and brakes keep working, but the car can't accelerate. 4.2% of these complaints involve a crash and 23.5% mention a highway. Signal, use the momentum to reach the shoulder, and get the car checked before driving on.

dataengines-transmissionsrecallsreliabilityused-cars
Denis Kataev
Founder & Editor · Serial Solopreneur

Denis Kataev is a serial solopreneur and the founder of ForCar. With 15+ years in software engineering and 10 years in SEO, he builds data-driven products end to end — backed by a sharp eye for design. At ForCar he mines proprietary vehicle datasets, turning raw numbers into buying advice you can actually trust.

Keep reading

All articles →
Found this useful?

Mark ForCar as a preferred source and our data shows up first in your Google results. One click, no account.

Prefer ForCar →