We hold 23,918 vehicles that appear in more than one listing — relisted after failing to sell. Comparing the first asking price against the last shows what sellers concluded from the failure.
| On relisting | Vehicles | Average change |
|---|---|---|
| Price unchanged | 17,406 | 72.8% |
| Price cut | 5,845 | −$1,015 (−6.4%) |
| Price raised | 667 | +$1,296 |
Nearly three quarters change nothing
The car sat, nobody bought it, and 17,406 sellers concluded the fix was more exposure rather than a lower number.
Some of them do this repeatedly. 12,456 vehicles appear twice, 4,752 three times, 838 six times — and 132 have been listed ten times. Ten attempts at the same price is not a pricing strategy, it's a belief.
And 667 went up
Nearly seven hundred sellers responded to not selling by asking for more, averaging $1,296 extra.
Some of that is legitimate — a car repaired or serviced between listings, or a seller who initially undervalued it. But at that volume most of it is anchoring: the owner has decided what the car is worth and reads a failed sale as proof they were too cheap.
What this tells you as a buyer
A relisted car is a negotiating position, not a fixed price. If the same vehicle has been on the market repeatedly at one number, that number has already been rejected by everyone who looked. You're not lowballing by opening below it — you're the first person to say out loud what the market has been saying silently.
Time on market is the leverage. A typical listing lasts under seven days, as we found in a used car listing lasts under seven days. A car on its third posting is far outside normal, and the seller knows it even if the price doesn't show it.
Ask directly how long they've been trying. Most will tell you. The answer sets the whole conversation.
The average successful cut is 6.4%. That's what sellers who do move actually move by — a useful anchor for what's realistic rather than hopeful.
One more thing worth checking
Relisted cars are also where we found discrepancies. Only 4.4% of relistings update the odometer at all, and 209 showed a lower reading the second time. A further 22 appeared with a clean title in one advert and a branded one in another.
So a car with a long listing history deserves both the negotiation and the check. A VIN check covers the second part in seconds.
Frequently asked questions
Do sellers lower the price when a car doesn't sell?
Usually not. Of 23,918 relisted vehicles, 17,406 — 72.8% — kept an identical price. Only 24.4% cut, and 667 sellers actually raised the asking price.
How much do sellers cut when they do?
An average of $1,015, or 6.4% of the asking price. That's a useful anchor for what a realistic reduction looks like versus a hopeful one.
How can I tell if a car has been relisted?
Ask the seller how long they've been trying — most will say. A typical listing lasts under seven days, so a car on its second or third posting is well outside normal, and 132 vehicles in our data have been listed ten times.
Should I negotiate harder on a relisted car?
The price has already been rejected by everyone who looked at it. Opening below it isn't lowballing — though it's also worth checking the history, since only 4.4% of relistings update the odometer and some show conflicting details.
Denis Kataev is a serial solopreneur and the founder of ForCar. With 15+ years in software engineering and 10 years in SEO, he builds data-driven products end to end — backed by a sharp eye for design. At ForCar he mines proprietary vehicle datasets, turning raw numbers into buying advice you can actually trust.
Keep reading
All articles →
Sellers Who Publish the VIN Ask 11% More — and Get It
You'd expect a seller who opens the car up to scrutiny to be the one making concessions. Matched like for like, they charge more than the sellers who don't.
A 2009 Car Costs More Than a 2010. The Recession Is Still Doing It.
Cars get cheaper as they get older. Except for one model year, where the car that's twelve months newer is the one that costs less — and the reason happened in 2009.
The Worse a Car's Title, the Less Likely the Seller Shows You the VIN
A missing VIN usually means a lazy listing. But sorted by title status, the pattern is too clean to be laziness — and the cars hiding it hardest are the expensive ones.