Buy the Last Year of the Old Shape: Redesigned Models Ask 18% to 50% More

Neighboring model years usually differ by a few percent. Across a redesign the gap jumps to a fifth, a third or even half, which makes the last year of an old generation one of the best-value buys on the used market.

By ·Nov 18, 2026·2 min read
Illustration of a full-size SUV
Share

In our listings, two neighboring model years of the same car usually differ by 5% to 8% in asking price at the same mileage. That's the normal cost of being one year newer.

When a model is redesigned, the step is much bigger. A 2021 Chevrolet Tahoe, the first of a new generation, asks 47% more than a 2020 with the same mileage. That's about eight years' worth of the Tahoe's normal year-to-year difference, crossed in one.

FIG.01·Price step at the start of a new generation, same mileage band
ModelFirst year of new generationPrice step from previous yearTypical year-to-year step
Chevrolet Suburban2021+49.6%6.9%
Mercedes-Benz C-Class2015+47.6%9.6%
Chevrolet Tahoe2021+47.4%5.0%
Chevrolet Traverse2018+40.8%7.4%
BMW X32018+38.8%3.3%
Nissan Altima2019+36.0%7.5%
Hyundai Sonata2020+35.3%8.1%
Ford Explorer2020+32.8%9.1%
Ford Mustang2015+30.6%4.6%
Toyota Prius2016+25.6%6.8%
Honda Civic2016+23.6%5.8%
Ford F-1502015+20.7%7.0%
Toyota RAV42019+18.4%6.4%
Toyota Camry2018+18.2%6.0%
ROWS 14·SOURCE ForCar listings data, June–October 2026

The comparison controls for mileage band, state, type of seller and month, so the step reflects the model year itself. The biggest jumps line up with known generation changes, and the table lists only those.

In dollars

At around 75,000 miles, the median 2020 Tahoe in our data asks $31,888 and the median 2021 asks $42,640. A 2019 Explorer at similar mileage asks $17,900, against $23,900 for the redesigned 2020. A 2014 F-150 asks $17,900 against $22,248 for the aluminum-bodied 2015.

Why the last year of the old shape is the deal

Part of the premium pays for real change: better crash structures, newer driver assistance, often better fuel economy. Much of it pays for the look. The new shape is what buyers want, and the old one suddenly looks dated even though it's only a year older.

Meanwhile the last year of a generation is usually the most developed version of it. Problems found in earlier years have been fixed on the production line, and the final year sometimes comes with extra standard equipment. The common advice to avoid the first year of a new model is weaker than it sounds: across hundreds of models, first years get slightly fewer recalls than later ones. The price difference, though, is consistent and large.

When the new generation is worth it

When the change is substantial, it can be. For a family SUV, a newer generation might bring a much better crash test result or automatic emergency braking as standard. Check the safety ratings of both generations on our safety rankings before deciding the premium is only cosmetic.

When the change is mostly styling, the last year of the old generation buys the most car for the money, typically a fifth to a third less for the same mileage. To find the boundary, look for a sudden jump in prices between two model years. A gap many times the usual step almost always marks a new generation.

The gap matters when you sell too. A car from the last year of an old generation competes with the new shape on every used lot, and its price reflects that. Our value estimator prices each model year separately, so you can see where yours falls.

Frequently asked questions

Is the last year of a car generation a good buy?

Usually, on price. At the same mileage, the first year of a new generation asks 18% to 50% more than the last year of the old one in our data, against a normal 5% to 8% gap between neighboring years. The last year is also typically the most developed version of the old design.

How much more does a redesigned model cost used?

Examples at the same mileage: 2021 Tahoe +47% over the 2020, 2020 Explorer +33% over the 2019, 2016 Civic +24% over the 2015, 2015 F-150 +21% over the 2014, and 2018 Camry +18% over the 2017.

Should you avoid the first year of a new model?

The reliability case is weaker than people think: across hundreds of models, first years get slightly fewer recalls than later years. The stronger reason is price: the first year of a new generation carries a large premium over the last year of the old one.

buying-advicedatapricingresale-valueused-cars
Denis Kataev
Founder & Editor · Serial Solopreneur

Denis Kataev is a serial solopreneur and the founder of ForCar. With 15+ years in software engineering and 10 years in SEO, he builds data-driven products end to end — backed by a sharp eye for design. At ForCar he mines proprietary vehicle datasets, turning raw numbers into buying advice you can actually trust.

Keep reading

All articles →
Found this useful?

Mark ForCar as a preferred source and our data shows up first in your Google results. One click, no account.

Prefer ForCar →